Auto Duct Line Acceptance Test - FAT and SAT Checklist
1
The final payment on a duct line should follow an acceptance test, not a phone call from the sales manager promising that "the video we sent shows everything works." I have sat through enough acceptance runs on both sides of the table to know that a structured FAT and SAT process protects the buyer, and honestly protects the manufacturer too, because it stops vague complaints from turning into warranty fights later. What follows is the checklist we hand to customers, lightly edited into something any plant manager can run without us standing in the room. FAT and SAT are different tests. Do not merge them.The Factory Acceptance Test happens at the manufacturer's shop before shipment. The Site Acceptance Test happens after installation and commissioning at your plant. Some buyers skip the FAT and wait for SAT. I understand the temptation, because traveling to a factory is a cost, but the FAT is where material and build problems get caught while they are still the seller's problem and still in the seller's building. Once the machine is bolted down in your workshop, every fix involves shipping, customs, and schedules, and suddenly a two-hour adjustment becomes a three-week negotiation. If travel is impossible, a live video FAT works. Insist it is live and interactive, not a recording, and that you get to name the test pieces. The FAT: what to bring and what to watchBring your own coil if you can, or at least specify the exact material the test runs on. A line demonstrated on 0.8 mm galvanized will look brilliant, then struggle on your 1.0 mm stock with a different coating. For a rectangular line, the standard test set we run is 1000 x 400 mm duct at 0.8 mm galvanized for the main run, plus the smallest size your catalog includes, because tiny ducts stress the beading and folding stations in ways big ducts never do. Watch these items in order. First, coil loading and leveling: the strip should feed without the leveler hunting, and the edge should track center within a few millimeters all the way to the cut station. Second, the cut: count burrs. A clean guillotine or plasma cut on 0.8 mm should need almost no deburring. Third, beading: check bead depth consistency across the full panel width; a bead that fades near the edges means roll pressure or roll wear issues. Fourth, folding: measure the flange, then measure it again ten minutes later after twenty more panels, because thermal drift and loose encoders show up as creeping dimensions. The honest throughput number is the one most often fudged. Ask for pieces per hour on the agreed test size, run continuously, with material changes included. A claimed "20 seconds per piece" that excludes loading and indexing is marketing, not production. On a well-configured U-shape auto duct line, a realistic continuous rate for 1000 x 400 at 0.8 mm is one completed L-shaped piece every 35 to 50 seconds depending on bead count and fold complexity. If the demo beats that dramatically, ask what was different. The SAT: your floor, your power, your operatorsSite acceptance proves the line works in your world, not in the showroom. Before the test run, close out three prerequisites. Power quality at the machine, measured under load, within the nameplate window. Anchor and leveling of the line sections, checked with a precision level along the feed line; a line out of level by more than 0.5 mm per meter will walk its accuracy all day. And operators trained enough to run the test themselves, because a SAT run by the supplier's engineer proves nothing about your team. Then run first-article inspection on five consecutive pieces. Measure flange width on all four sides, corner squareness with a diagonal check, bead positions, and the finished opening dimensions. The acceptance band we use, aligned with common HVAC ductwork standards, is flange width within plus-or-minus 1 mm, diagonal difference under 2 mm for a 1000 mm panel, and square-cut ends within 1 mm. Record the numbers on paper, both parties sign, and that sheet becomes your baseline for every maintenance argument later. The acceptance checklist, condensed
Spare parts and documentation: the quiet half of acceptanceA line that runs perfectly on day one and stops on day forty because a $12 sensor died and nobody stocks it is a failed acceptance in spirit. Before you sign anything, go through the recommended spare parts list with the engineer, not the salesman. You are looking for three tiers. Consumables you will burn through monthly: plasma electrodes and nozzles, shear blades eventually, bead roll sets for each material family. Wear parts with a year or two of life: belts, filters, encoder cables that flex across the feed. And the long-tail electronics: proximity switches, solenoid valves, one spare servo drive if the line has more than four axes. Price the package before final payment, because the discount you negotiate on spares bundled with the machine is always better than buying them a year later under pressure. Documentation is the other half. The electrical diagrams must match the machine in front of you, not a generic template, so spot-check three wire numbers during the FAT. Demand the PLC program backup on a USB stick in front of you, plus the HMI project file. If the supplier hesitates on the program backup, negotiate it at order time, because after payment your leverage drops to zero. One page in the contract, one line item in the punch list, no drama. Training that actually sticksOperator training is part of acceptance, and it has a measurable test: your people run the line without the supplier's engineer touching anything for one full shift. Not a demonstration, a shift. Size changeovers, material loading, alarm recovery, plasma consumable change, daily lubrication. If your operators cannot close a servo alarm themselves, they will call the supplier for every hiccup, and response times across time zones are measured in days. Write the training hours into the schedule and hold two of them in reserve for the second and third week, after your team has found their own questions. Video everything during training. The adjustment of bead roll pressure, the folding back-gauge zeroing routine, the plasma arc voltage tuning, these are thirty-second clips that save you a week of remote support later. The best buyers I work with keep a shared video folder per machine, and their downtime numbers show it. The three games, and how to defuse themGame one is the pristine demo coil. Fresh, perfectly coated, dead-flat stock that no shop ever receives. Defuse it by sending your material spec in advance and testing on comparable coil. Game two is the cherry-picked rate. One brilliant minute, timed once. Defuse it by contractually setting a continuous 30-minute run with changeovers included. Game three is the moving-target punch list: issues raised during FAT get reclassified as "training topics" instead of defects. Defuse it with a written punch list, each item numbered, closed items signed off, open items linked to the final payment milestone. One more practical tip from experience: include the plasma unit in both tests if your line has one. Plasma is the subsystem most likely to behave beautifully at the factory and act up on your air supply. Arc transfer, pierce consistency, and consumable life all depend on the air dryer and the site compressor, so make the SAT include a full 8-hour production shift with the plasma cutting every panel. A line that punches 200 clean CNC plasma cut panels in a shift has earned its final payment; one that loses arc every fifth pierce has not, and better to know it in week one. And if your scope includes round duct, put the spiral machine through the same discipline. A spiral tubeformer has its own acceptance points, mostly seam quality and diameter consistency across the size range, and it deserves its own signed sheet rather than a rider on the rectangular line's report. Frequently asked questionsWho pays for the FAT visit?Customary practice splits it: the manufacturer provides the machine time, material, and engineers; the buyer covers travel. Video FAT is a fair substitute if the buyer names the test pieces and it is run live. What if the line passes FAT but fails SAT?The contract should say it plainly: final payment or a defined percentage holds until SAT passes at the buyer's site on the buyer's material and power. That is standard for export machinery and a supplier who resists it is telling you something. How long should commissioning and SAT take?For a standard rectangular line, plan 5 to 7 working days on site including training, with SAT runs in the last two days. Anything promised in 48 hours is a machine that was never really commissioned. Which documents must I receive at acceptance?At minimum: electrical schematics, PLC program backup, mechanical layout with foundation plan, recommended spare parts list with consumable part numbers, and the signed inspection record from FAT. Get them before the final payment clears, not after. |